The theme is setup with a child theme. The child theme’s url is weird:
http://27colony.com/wp-content/themes/fingerlakes1/A.style.css,qver=8eb6c14d8798798d610cea8b369be279.pagespeed.cf.1B2M2Y8Asg.css
There’s a prefix “A.” in front of style.css which is preventing it from loading correctly. The qver added with the comma is also very odd.
We chose your theme because you say that the theme is child theme compatible and it fit all of our display requirements.